Don't Tell a Soul

Jack Dylan Grazer

Joey

Fionn Whitehead

Matt

Rainn Wilson

Mr. Hamby / Randy Michael Sadler

Mena Suvari

Carol

Graham Lutes

Tom Chowdee

Richard Fike

Officer Smith

Abigail Esmena Froehle

Officer Crane

McKenna Christine Poe

Teenage Girl on Car

Kate Duncan

Teenage Girl at Party

Seth Poe

Teenage Boy at Party

Shannon Cogan

News Anchor

Brian Tanke

Plunkett

Max Neace

Plunkett Jr.